MUNICH — Drake Maye’s injury has left New England weighing how to keep its offense functioning without him. One proposed answer would bring back a familiar quarterback, but the suggestion has come from outside the Patriots, not from a team announcement.
ESPN Radio host Evan Cohen has floated Jimmy Garoppolo as a possible addition if Maye misses an extended period. His argument centers on familiarity with offensive coordinator Josh McDaniels, rather than a claim that New England is negotiating a reunion.
The distinction is important for a 5–5 team awaiting more information about its starting quarterback. Maye left Sunday’s 35–10 loss to Detroit with an ankle injury, and the Patriots have a Week 11 bye before visiting the Chargers. Their immediate question is how long they must plan to play without him.
Cohen wrote in his post on X that, if Maye is absent for an extended period, the Patriots “may need to sign Jimmy G.” He added that they needed someone who knew the McDaniels offense quickly, closing with: “Yep, it’s come to that.”
That is a conditional recommendation. It does not establish an offer, a workout, contact between the parties or interest from Garoppolo. None of those steps is confirmed by the reporting underpinning the suggestion.
Mike Florio reported for NBC Sports that the Patriots currently expect Maye to be out “a while,” citing a source with knowledge of the situation. That report did not provide a precise absence or a confirmed diagnosis. Further testing remained part of the assessment.
Without Maye, Tommy DeVito is the starter and rookie Behren Morton the backup. The bye creates time to prepare, but its value depends on information New England did not yet have publicly: whether Maye’s absence will end near the break or extend into the remaining schedule.
Garoppolo’s appeal in Cohen’s proposal is the potential to shorten a learning period. His history with McDaniels includes their time together in New England and later with the Raiders. Familiarity would be a starting point, not proof that he could immediately reproduce Maye’s role or solve the broader problems exposed against Detroit.
The Lions’ win showed why the quarterback discussion cannot be separated from the rest of the team. In its completed-game report, NBC Sports recorded 153 rushing yards and two rushing touchdowns for Jahmyr Gibbs, along with seven catches for 99 yards. New England’s defense had problems that a change at quarterback would not address.
The Patriots had entered the game with uncertainty around their receiving options, too. A.J. Brown’s availability against Detroit was a pregame concern; he subsequently left the game with a hamstring injury, NBC Sports reported. Maye’s departure was the largest disruption to the offense, but it was not the only one.
New England’s position makes the distinction between a temporary replacement and a longer-term contingency consequential. After the Chargers, the Patriots face the Bills and Vikings at home, followed by a Monday night trip to Kansas City. A short absence and a prolonged one would present very different preparation demands.
There is also a difference between knowing an offense and being ready to run its current version with its current personnel. Cohen’s proposal addresses the first problem. It supplies no verified answer to the second, and no evidence that the Patriots have chosen Garoppolo over the quarterbacks already on their roster.
The familiar name makes an easy headline. The unresolved detail remains Maye’s ankle: until the tests establish more about his recovery, even the length of the vacancy Cohen wants Garoppolo to fill is uncertain.

