The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping has drawn criticism from The Atlantic for relying too heavily on familiar characters and callbacks, as the franchise returns to the story of a teenage Haymitch Abernathy. The publication’s review argues that the prequel struggles to develop the emotional and political stakes that distinguished the earlier films.
Yahoo Entertainment, in an article updated on November 20, reports that the sixth Hunger Games film is reaching cinemas that day. Its accompanying comparison of the five previous instalments places Catching Fire first, but explicitly excludes the new release because it is too early to rank it alongside its predecessors. The release is also the subject of The Eastern Herald’s Sunrise on the Reaping box-office report.
Haymitch’s past becomes the focus
Directed by Francis Lawrence, Sunrise on the Reaping stars Joseph Zada as 16-year-old Haymitch. The story follows him into the Second Quarter Quell, a special edition of the Hunger Games featuring twice the usual number of competitors, known as tributes. The Eastern Herald previously covered the film’s London premiere.
The character was played by Woody Harrelson in the original films, where the former Games winner mentors Jennifer Lawrence’s Katniss Everdeen. The new prequel revisits his life before that relationship and his later involvement in resistance to Panem’s rulers.
It follows the franchise’s earlier prequel, The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes, which explored the youth of Coriolanus Snow and how the Games developed into mass entertainment.
The Atlantic questions the film’s reliance on callbacks
The Atlantic’s review argues that Sunrise on the Reaping covers too much narrative ground without giving sufficient attention to Haymitch’s motivations. It identifies familiar scenes, appearances by younger versions of established characters and dialogue echoing earlier films as examples of nostalgia displacing character development.
The review also criticises the action sequences and computer-generated arena threats, arguing that the crowded cast leaves viewers with too little opportunity to become invested in individual tributes. These are the publication’s assessments, not a verified consensus among critics or audiences.
Its response is not uniformly negative about the performances. The review singles out Jesse Plemons for an understated contribution, while arguing that actors including Lili Taylor, Maya Hawke, McKenna Grace and Ben Wang receive underdeveloped roles.
Catching Fire leads Yahoo’s comparison of earlier films
Separately, Yahoo Entertainment compares the five earlier Hunger Games films using Rotten Tomatoes critics’ scores, Metacritic critics’ scores and IMDb user ratings. The article distinguishes the critics’ assessments on the first two platforms from the audience ratings on IMDb.
Yahoo places Catching Fire first, reporting that it leads across all three measures. The original The Hunger Games comes second, followed by the two Mockingjay films, with The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes last in its comparison.
The feature does not include Sunrise on the Reaping in that ranking. Its findings therefore describe the reception of the earlier films, rather than establishing where the new Haymitch prequel belongs within the series.

