MIAMI — Lionel Messi was allowed to finish a playoff game that Columbus’ coach argued he should have left before halftime. By the end, Inter Miami CF had more than the captain’s yellow card to worry about: one more defeat will end their title defence.
The seventh-seeded Columbus Crew won 3-0 on Saturday in Game 1 of their best-of-three first-round series against the Eastern Conference’s second seed. Gonzalo Tapia scored twice, Taha Habroune added the other goal and Miami finished with ten players.
The player sent off was Gonzalo Luján, who received a second yellow card in the 36th minute. Messi and Tapia were cautioned separately after the throw-in incident in first-half stoppage time, when Miami were already a man and a goal down. The dispute concerns whether Messi should also have been dismissed, not whether he actually received a red card.
According to Al Jazeera’s account, Tapia was less than a metre away and trying to impede the restart when Messi threw the ball into his face. Columbus interim coach Laurent Courtois said Messi deserved more than a caution, telling reporters: “Everybody knows that he deserved more than a yellow card.”
Chapman offered a different assessment. Al Jazeera quoted the referee telling a pool reporter that “the force used was negligible, and the offence did not reach the level of violent conduct”. That is the official’s explanation of the decision he made, rather than an assertion that the contact did not happen.

The FAQ also considers an irritated thrower who deliberately throws the ball at that opponent. Both players receive the appropriate disciplinary sanction: a reckless throw brings a yellow card for the thrower, while excessive force brings a red for violent conduct. The opponent’s interference therefore does not provide a blanket exemption from punishment for the response.
A separate provision allows a correctly taken throw-in to be deliberately rebounded off an opponent so the thrower can play the ball again, provided it is not careless, reckless or excessively forceful. That limited allowance is not a rule that every deliberate throw at another player must go unpunished, nor does every such throw automatically require a red card.
Those provisions explain the threshold at issue. They are not an independent refereeing verdict on Messi’s action. The published accounts reviewed for this report did not include an additional MLS disciplinary ruling on the incident; Chapman’s on-field caution should not be confused with a guarantee about any possible later league action.
Miami coach Kily Gonzalez did not make the referee his explanation for the defeat. Al Jazeera quoted him saying: “The referee saw a yellow, and that is it. We can’t blame the referee.” He also said Miami had effectively created the visitors’ chances and needed to learn from a game in which things had gone wrong.

The scoreline did not mean Columbus had been comfortable throughout. Patrick Schulte made five saves, including important first-half stops against Messi from close range and from a free kick. Keeping Miami out during that spell protected the lead before Columbus could exploit the extra player after halftime.
Official MLS match highlights:
The meeting had begun with recognition of Messi’s regular-season scoring. He received the Golden Boot before kickoff after producing 26 goals and 17 assists. The award and Miami’s second-place conference finish did not translate into a home advantage strong enough to overcome the Crew on Saturday.

Under the league’s published series format, the first team to win two matches advances. Game 2 is in Columbus on Friday, November 27, at 8 p.m. ET. A Miami victory would force a deciding game at home on December 2; a Columbus win would eliminate the defending champions.
Miami do not have to erase an aggregate three-goal deficit. Any Game 2 win would make the series one match apiece. If the teams are level after 90 minutes, there is no extra time in this round: a penalty shootout determines the winner. The size of Saturday’s defeat does not create a requirement to win Friday by four goals.
For Columbus, the attacking contribution was backed by work at the other end. In the league’s published reaction, Courtois said Schulte had been “incredible all year long” and praised the consistency of his performances. His goalkeeper’s two first-half stops against Messi helped leave the Crew with something more useful than the outcome of an argument: a clean sheet and the first win.

