The Epstein Files have drawn renewed attention after forensic scientist Michael Freeman challenged the official finding that Jeffrey Epstein died by suicide. Presenting his analysis on November 16 at an event hosted by London’s Middle Temple, Freeman offered a different interpretation of the autopsy findings. New York City’s Office of Chief Medical Examiner stands by its determination that hanging was the cause of death and suicide was the manner.
The FBI concluded that Epstein’s death did not result from a criminal act. A 2023 Justice Department inspector general report found no evidence contradicting that conclusion, while documenting missed checks, a failure to replace his cellmate and gaps in recorded surveillance.
Those documented jail failures are distinct from Freeman’s claim that Epstein’s injuries were more consistent with strangulation than with suicide. His interpretation remains disputed and has not changed the official determination.
What Freeman’s analysis argues
Freeman told BBC Newsnight that, after reviewing medical examiner materials, he believed Epstein was most likely strangled from behind.
His analysis focused on the marks on Epstein’s neck and other injuries, including bleeding deep in the left shoulder. He interpreted those findings as evidence of an assault. His presentation offered a competing interpretation of existing case materials, not a new official finding.
Freeman did not examine Epstein’s body. His analysis was based on records, photographs and a reconstruction, and had not been peer-reviewed. Materials were supplied by Epstein’s brother, Mark, who has long disputed the suicide ruling.
“The injuries that were documented by the medical examiner were not consistent with the suicidal hanging,” Freeman told CBS News. That is his assessment, not the medical examiner’s conclusion.
The official determination remains unchanged
Dr. Kristin Roman performed Epstein’s autopsy on August 11, 2019. Then-Chief Medical Examiner Dr. Barbara Sampson issued the official determination. The medical examiner’s assessment considered the overall injury pattern consistent with hanging.
There was disagreement in 2019 as well. Dr. Michael Baden, a pathologist retained by Mark Epstein to observe the autopsy, publicly argued that the neck fractures looked more consistent with strangulation. The medical examiner interpreted the findings differently.
Responding to Freeman’s challenge, a spokesperson for the medical examiner told CBS News: “Our office stands by its determination.”
What the jail failed to do
The Epstein Files also draw attention to documented failures at the jail. The inspector general found missed checks, inaccurate records and failures to follow instructions intended to keep Epstein under supervision. He was awaiting trial on federal sex-trafficking charges when he died.
Epstein’s cellmate was transferred to another facility on August 9 and was not replaced, despite a written Psychology Department directive that Epstein be housed with an appropriate cellmate.
The two officers assigned to the unit did not complete required rounds or counts. They later entered deferred-prosecution agreements over falsified records. The charges were dismissed after the officers successfully completed the agreements.
The report also identified failures to search Epstein’s cell adequately, allowing excess bedding to accumulate. These findings established serious failures in his custody and supervision; they did not establish that he was killed.
The discovery and the limits of surveillance
According to the inspector general, staff began delivering breakfast at approximately 6:30 a.m. on August 10. Officer Michael Thomas opened Epstein’s locked cell after he did not respond and found him hanging. Additional jail employees responded at approximately 6:33 a.m.
A recorder malfunction on July 29 left many cameras without stored footage, although their live feeds continued. Staff discovered the recording failure on August 8, but it was not repaired before Epstein’s death.
The available recording did not show Epstein’s cell door and provided only a partial view of the stairways. However, the inspector general concluded that anyone entering or attempting to enter his tier from the common area would have been captured.
Investigators reported seeing no such entry between approximately 10:40 p.m. and 6:30 a.m. That finding describes the route visible in the available recording; the recording did not show what happened inside Epstein’s cell.
What the Epstein Files establish
Earlier reporting on the release of a purported suicide note also distinguished public access to a document from authentication of its authorship.
Freeman’s challenge has not changed the official suicide determination. The inspector general’s findings establish serious failures of custody and supervision, but not homicide. Keeping those conclusions separate allows scrutiny of the jail’s documented conduct without presenting a disputed forensic interpretation as an established fact.

