LONDON — The last image of Moises Caicedo in competitive football was him walking slowly toward the touchline at the Amex, 14 minutes after coming on as a substitute in Chelsea’s 4-3 win over Brighton, one hand raised toward the bench, one more setback in a season that has barely started.
That picture is the defining one for Chelsea as they travel to the Emirates on Sunday afternoon. Not the three-goal lead they twice surrendered. Not Romeo Lavia’s thunderstrike that eventually settled it. The slow walk of their best midfielder toward the medical room again, for the second time in three Premier League games, while Xabi Alonso stood on the touchline and did the arithmetic.
With Enzo Fernandez sold to Manchester City on deadline day and a late move for Lamine Camara collapsing in acrimony with Monaco, Alonso enters his first marquee fixture without the midfield he was building around. What he has instead is Lavia, a 21-year-old Belgian with a low centre of gravity and a growing sense that this season will define him, and Reece James, the club captain redeployed centrally in a formation that neither manager nor player fully explained before August ended.
“We will check tomorrow,” Alonso told reporters on Friday when asked about Caicedo. He has been checking every week since August. The answer keeps coming back the same.
Chelsea signed Caicedo for a then-British-record fee in 2023. He has been the best central midfielder in the Premier League in seasons where Chelsea did not fully deserve him. This year he has managed 14 minutes of competitive football since limping out of the Fulham opener. The pattern is not encouraging, and Alonso’s refusal to set a timeline is its own kind of assessment.
The Ecuador captain is not the only absence. Jordan Henderson, whose World Cup campaign lasted longer than Stamford Bridge would have wished, is out with a wrist injury. Marco Palestra, whose arrival from Inter Milan had been one of the summer’s quieter pieces of business, is also unavailable. The midfield that faces Arsenal at 4:30pm BST on Sunday will be built around Lavia and a collection of players covering positions that were never originally theirs.
What Alonso has done in this situation is quietly interesting. Rather than treat Reece James as a right back doing favours in the centre of the pitch, the manager has reorganised the entire system around James at the base, using his range of passing and his composure under pressure in tight areas. Against Brighton, the system conceded three and survived once, on Lavia’s strike from the edge of the area that turned a likely draw into a win. The margin for error at the Emirates will be considerably smaller.
That 4-3 win over Brighton revealed both realities at once: Cole Palmer remains capable of being the most dangerous attacking midfielder in England, and Chelsea’s defensive structure without Caicedo is vulnerable to sides that move quickly in transition. Arsenal, whose unbeaten start to the season followed a 3-0 demolition of Manchester City in the Community Shield, are precisely that kind of team.
Mikel Arteta’s side enters Sunday with something to prove and the quiet confidence that comes from an unbeaten opening built on defensive cohesion. Chelsea were expected to be their most serious rivals for the title. The Fernandez sale and Caicedo’s injury diary have shaken those assumptions at Stamford Bridge faster than any league table has moved.
The attacking picture is more settled. Morgan Rogers, whose £117m move from Aston Villa made him the most expensive British transfer in history, has been paired behind Palmer and Joao Pedro in a three-man unit that created chances against Fulham and Brighton alike. At the Emirates, where space is more narrowly controlled than at most grounds in the division, his ability to arrive late between the lines will be the thing that creates the openings.
Alonso said on Friday that he was satisfied with what the window produced and that the squad was in good shape for now and for the future. He said of Fernandez’s departure: “We take all the decisions together. What he has done for the club has been great, but now it is time to move forward.” According to Yahoo Sports, he had called Caicedo one of the best holding midfielders in the world, praise that makes the fact he has played 14 competitive minutes this season a particular kind of problem.
What Chelsea lack, right now, is a safety net. Fernandez was that net, the player who absorbed pressure in transition, who could receive the ball in tight situations and turn it into something useful. He is at the Etihad now. The void he left is not a problem Lamine Camara alone would have solved, but at least it would have been a problem with a person assigned to it.
Instead it falls to Lavia, who scored the winner against Brighton and who is 21 years old and who has never anchored Chelsea’s midfield in a London derby at the Emirates as first-choice pivot. He will have Reece James for company and a manager who demonstrated, through 34 unbeaten Bundesliga games at Bayer Leverkusen, that he can get teams performing beyond what the circumstances predict.
Whether that holds on Sunday is the question no Friday press conference can answer. The 4:30pm kickoff at the Emirates will.
Related Posts
