GENEVA — Governments have agreed to begin drafting international rules for autonomous weapons but left unresolved whether those rules will carry legal force, disappointing campaigners who sought an immediate commitment to a binding treaty on machines that can select and attack targets without a person making the final decision to fire.
The compromise emerged in the early hours of November 21 after a week of negotiations at the United Nations in Geneva. Switzerland, which chaired the conference, said the 128 states party to the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons had agreed to draw up an instrument during 2027 and 2028. Its legal form will be determined after that work concludes.
That distinction defines the outcome. Governments agreed to develop an instrument, not to adopt a ban, and not to guarantee that the eventual text would become a legally binding protocol. The majority wanted a mandate explicitly directed toward binding rules, but the convention’s consensus requirement prevented agreement on that approach.
For states demanding tighter limits, the compromise keeps the issue moving while leaving its most consequential question unanswered. For the military powers resisting binding restrictions, it preserves room to shape both the substance of the rules and their eventual legal status. The timetable is now clearer than the obligation governments might ultimately accept, according to the outcome described in Switzerland’s official announcement.
The United States, Russia and Israel opposed the push for binding rules, Al Jazeera reported. Diplomats said Russian procedural objections caused some formal sessions to be called off, while negotiations over the final wording continued through the night. The Swiss government’s account emphasized that all major military powers remained within the agreed process.
Julien Thöni, Switzerland’s ambassador to the Conference on Disarmament and president of the review conference, said some countries had rejected even the word “negotiate,” according to Al Jazeera. The agreed language instead refers to the “elaboration” of an instrument. Switzerland said Thöni worked with Peru’s ambassador, Elmer Schialer Salcedo, to bridge the differences.
The competing descriptions of the result reflect different tests of success. Switzerland presented an agreement among the major military powers to draft an instrument as progress after more than a decade of discussions. Campaigners judged the outcome against the commitment they had sought: negotiations that would deliver enforceable prohibitions and restrictions, rather than another process whose destination remains uncertain.
Stop Killer Robots, a coalition of nongovernmental organizations, called the mandate “watered down” and said it offered no clear route to legally binding rules. Its executive director, Nicole van Rooijen, warned that autonomous weapons were already being deployed in combat, including systems using artificial intelligence to choose targets. Delaying a binding instrument, she said, “puts civilians and humanity at risk,” Al Jazeera reported.
The International Committee of the Red Cross had urged governments to take a more definite step. In a statement prepared for the conference and published November 18, it called for a one-year negotiating mandate for a new protocol. It argued that the work of the convention’s government experts provided a sufficient basis to start, despite the organization’s reservations about omissions in their report.
The ICRC’s proposed approach was not a blanket prohibition on every autonomous function in a military system. It called for prohibitions on unpredictable autonomous weapons and those designed or used to target human beings directly, alongside clear restrictions on other systems. Its stated objective was to preserve meaningful human control over the use of force.
The organization also stressed that autonomous weapons are already governed by international humanitarian law. The failure to agree on new binding rules therefore does not mean such weapons operate outside existing law. The dispute concerns whether governments will adopt additional, specific limits to address the humanitarian, ethical, legal and security problems that autonomous targeting raises.
That distinction matters because the conference was deciding how to develop new rules, not establishing that every AI-assisted weapon is lawful or unlawful. The ICRC argues that states must set boundaries before unacceptable systems become widely deployed, when the risks to civilians and international security would become harder to contain.
Eastern Herald’s earlier coverage of rifle-mounted robot dogs shown in a Haiti stadium operation illustrates the limits of identifying autonomy from footage alone. That report did not establish whether the machines selected targets autonomously or how they were controlled; their appearance is not evidence of autonomous targeting.
Support for further international action extends beyond the Geneva process. The ICRC said 163 states voted on October 29 for a UN General Assembly First Committee resolution calling for negotiations on an international instrument. That figure describes support in a different forum; it is not a count of governments that agreed to a binding treaty in Geneva.
The convention itself has previously produced specific restrictions on weapons. The ICRC pointed to its protocols on fragments undetectable by X-rays and blinding laser weapons as examples of governments acting before particular technologies became established in military arsenals. But it warned that the last convention prohibitions or restrictions on specific weapons dated back 30 years.
Verity Coyle, deputy director for arms at Human Rights Watch, said the Geneva result did not provide the urgent action needed while technology continued advancing, Al Jazeera reported. Switzerland acknowledged that the main work still lay ahead. The agreement gives governments two years to draft an instrument; whether they will then accept it as binding remains a separate decision.

